next up previous
Next: References Up: Solar energetic particles: A Previous: Impulsive Flare Events

Conclusions

During the last few years there has been a shift in the paradigm of solar particle acceleration based on improved measurements of particles and their correlation with solar phenomena. We now recognize that the particles in most of the largest events are accelerated over a large spatial region by the shock wave ahead of a CME, not in a solar flare. The particles that are accelerated in association with impulsive flares have unusual He-rich, Fe-rich abundances resulting from electron-beam induced resonant wave-particle interactions in the flare. In fact, particle abundances and ionization states have become a tool that can distinguish the two mechanisms of acceleration, even in some events where both mechanisms are present [ Reames 1990b].

The identification of the particle sources has changed our ideas of particle transport. With extended shock acceleration, we no longer need ad hoc concepts like ``coronal diffusion'' to explain the longitude distribution or time profiles, and the particles stream outward from any source with only moderate scattering. In large events the time profiles tell us mostly about the evolution of the source and our connection to it, and almost nothing about particle transport from it.

Having the correct acceleration paradigm is of great practical importance if one is to predict particle events at Earth. The highest intensities and longest durations of 1-10 MeV protons are likely to come from CMEs launched near central meridian. The highest energy protons, accelerated fairly near the Sun in all cases, will come from events near 50 west. Highly ionizing Fe ions will be especially abundant at 1 AU when large impulsive flares occur at 40-70 west. As a large, magnetically-complex active region traverses the solar disk, the intensity, abundances, spectra and time profile of the particles that might be expected from events in the region will change with time.

We have only begun to understand the physics of particle acceleration in solar events and many questions remain. In the impulsive events the mechanism of acceleration of the intense electron beams is not clear, both electric-field and stochastic mechanisms seem possible. We cannot yet predict the abundances of all the elements in these events and the role of wave cascading is not clear. In the gradual events we do not know the structure, strength and time evolution of the shock far around on the flanks and especially in the corona. We are especially uncertain about the connectivity and topology of the magnetic field lines close behind the shock within the ``ejecta'' and still farther behind where field lines may be ``drawn out'' by the CME [see Reames 1994]. We cannot even predict the abundance variations that occur in different gradual events. Recognizing the approximate site of the acceleration is only the beginning.

It is now clear that the errors of the previous paradigm came about partly because of an excessive focus on protons. This made proton-poor events seem small and inconsequential so they were overlooked while great effort was lavished on fitting proton time profiles and anisotropies in large events. Much of our new understanding has come from the study of the abundances of elements and isotopes and of their ionization states. Not only do these ions tell us about the conditions in the source plasma but they have opened a new window on the complex plasma physics of particle acceleration. The existence of resonant wave interactions that enhance He by many orders of magnitude can not be inferred from photon observations of flares. Similar processes may be important in distant sources of astrophysical interest where direct particle observations are not possible.



next up previous
Next: References Up: Solar energetic particles: A Previous: Impulsive Flare Events



U.S. National Report to IUGG, 1991-1994
Rev. Geophys. Vol. 33 Suppl., © 1995 American Geophysical Union